Widow of Oil Field Consultant Awarded $1.2M in Asbestos-Exposure Case
Monday, 12 October 2009 17:20
TEXAS – October 7, 2009 – A Brazoria County jury has awarded the widow of Danny Puckett, an industrial engineer and oil field consultant, $1.2 million for asbestos exposure from 1975 to 1980 that lead to his malignant mesothelioma — a terminal illness that often claims its victims within 12 to 18 months of diagnosis.
The verdict, handed down on Monday, October 5, 2009, represents the first known asbestos drilling mud additive verdict in Texas. Montello, Inc. and Union Carbide – the only remaining defendants at trial – were each assessed 15-percent liability of the $1.2 million award for causing Mr. Puckett’s mesothelioma. Oklahoma law was applied to this case.
Mr. Puckett graduated from Oklahoma State University Tech with a degree in Industrial Engineering. In 1975 until 1985, he worked for Dowell Company as a member of the cement crew. Mr. Puckett eventually worked his way up to supervisor.
Mr. Puckett testified to breathing dust from the dumping of asbestos-containing cement additives into a mixing hopper at the bulk cement facility while working for Dowell Company. He used asbestos mud additives three to four times per week at a minimum for four to five years, and described a “continuous smokestack” of dust, to the point that one couldn’t see a street light.
Mr. Puckett started his own oil field consulting practice in the late 1990s and had planned on continuing to work well into his 60s. He was diagnosed with malignant mesothelioma in October 2008. He fought the disease for six months. Mr. Puckett leaves behind his wife of 23 years. He was 59-years-old.
About Waters & Kraus, LLP Waters & Kraus, LLP is a nationally recognized plaintiffs’ firm concentrating on complex product liability and personal injury/wrongful death cases, particularly asbestos-mesothelioma. In addition to toxic tort litigation, the firm’s diverse practice includes pharmaceutical product liability, negligence, elder financial abuse, class actions, and consumer product liability, as well as qui tam (whistleblower) and commercial litigation. With offices in Texas, California, and Maryland, Waters & Kraus, LLP has litigated cases in jurisdictions across the United States on behalf of individuals from all 50 states, as well as foreign governments.
— Case Fact Sheet Follows —
Case Fact Sheet
Case Style • Cause No. 49563 Puckett et al vs. Baker Hughes Incorporated et al • Trial length: 2 Weeks Deliberation Length: 1 Day
Jurisdiction • 23rd District Court, Brazoria County, Texas • Hon. Ben Hardin, presiding
Verdict • October 5, 2009 • $1.2M total award • Liability: 15% assigned to Union Carbide; 15% assigned to Montello, Inc. • Oklahoma law applied
Case Summary Danny Puckett, an industrial engineer and oil field consultant, was exposed to asbestos while working for Dowell Company on their cement crew from 1975 to 1980. Mr. Puckett breathed dust from dumping and mixing bags of asbestos-containing mud additives. Mr. Puckett was diagnosed with malignant mesothelioma in September 2008. The Brazoria County jury awarded Mr. Puckett’s widow $1.2 million for the asbestos exposure that caused his malignant mesothelioma. Union Carbide and Montello, Inc. were each assessed 15-percent liability. Oklahoma law was applied to this case. It is the first known drilling mud additive verdict in Texas. Mr. Puckett died six months after being diagnosed – he was 59-years-old.
Significance • Oklahoma law was applied to this case. • First known asbestos drilling mud additive verdict in Texas.
Plaintiffs Experts • Arnold Brody, Ph.D., cell biologist (live, testimony) • William Longo, Ph.D., material scientist • J. C. Maddox, M.D., pathology • Richard Thompson, economist
Defense Experts • Tim Oury, M.D., pathology (live, testimony) • Jack Walsh, Corporate Representative for Union Carbide • Allen Johnson, Corporate Representative for Montello
Defense Counsel • (Union Carbide) Hartline, Dacus, Barger, Dreyer & Kern, L.L.P. – CORPUS CHRISTI, TX Michael G. Terry • (Union Carbide) Baker Botts, L.L.P. Kevin M. Jordan • (Montello) Andrew S. Hartman, PC – TULSA, OK Andrew S. Hartman